My family took a day trip to the west coast of Florida, visiting first Sarasota and then Tarpon Springs. We were drawn to Tarpon because of the Greek community, sponge diving, and, of course, great Greek food.
Tarpon's main drag is Dodecanes Blvd., lined with small shops selling assortments of t-shirts, Greek fishermen caps, and sponges. I'm not sure what I expected sponges to be but they are...actually...sponges. Shocking. There are different types of sponges, some are just for decoration, others are good for washing, others for painting.
There are numerous Greek restaurants all on this one street. We stopped first for an afternoon snack at Hellas Restaurant and Bakery. I had seen it highlighted in Travel + Leisure's Florida Top 40 Places Only the Locals Know About. Hellas was noted for its delicious desserts.
The bakery itself is adjacent to the restaurant and is not very big. When you get a lot of people crowding around the display case, there isn't much room. Add the fact it was a nippy 45 degrees outside and everyone was bundled up, it became a tight squeeze. Hellas sold numerous traditional Greek desserts, as well as ice cream, carrot cake, cheesecake, and even some Italian specialties.
I wanted to try their Italian cannoli (up to that point I had never tried one); we also purchased a baklava, a flogeras, a giant cookie, and a saraigli. The cannoli didn't trip my trigger; the outer shell seemed stale and I wasn't fond of the flavor of the ricotta filling. I'd like to give it another shot from an Italian bakery. The baklava was good but super sweet; the sugar syrup and honey over powered the flavor of the nut filling. The flogeras is the cylinder shaped dessert with chocolate drizzled on top. The saraigli is the circular pastry with the cherry on top. Both the flogeras and the saraigli had walnut and honey (just like the baklava) and tasted just like the baklava, though perhaps not as sweet. The cookie was probably almond based but I only had a small bit so I'm not 100% sure. It did seem rather dry and lacked flavor. Overall, we were disappointed in the quality of Hellas' desserts. I've gotten better baklava here in Orlando--Ali Babba buffet in Longwood or Powerhouse Cafe in Winter Park (one of the owners, George, mother makes the baklava...killer!).
After dessert, we weren't sold on going to Hellas Restaurant even though it was ranked #1 at Trip Advisor. A store owner we asked about which restaurant he would eat at, said Mamma's Greek Restaurant because it was home cooking--the tag line for the restaurant is "Where the locals eat". Hellas, he said, was where the tourists always eat. As we went from store to store, my mom asked the owners or clerks where they would eat--Mamma's or Hellas. Most said Mamma's and one lady recommended Dimitri on the Water, which appeared to be more upscale than either Mamma's or Hellas.
We settled on Mamma's and entered the dimly lit restaurant guided by a pitch man who was working the side walk. He burst into song, serenading my 5 year old sister. We were sold.
We got a table right next to the kitchen window which proved to be both eye-opening and interesting. It wasn't too busy when we arrived but more people arrived throughout our meal, filling up the small space. Our waitress was very kind and answered our myriad of questions (we're curious folk). For starters, we had calamari and flaming cheese as well as complimentary loaves of what I assume was the Greek bread noted on the menu. The calamari was good, especially with lemon juice squeezed on them; the waitress also provided marinara sauce which was a nice contrast. The flaming cheese was quite a show--my brothers quickly agreed that any place that lets you play with fire was worth working at. The Greek bread tasted like a white French loaf. Both starters were good and I would order the calamari again.
Mmm, calamari; we didn't tell my brother what it was until after he ate it!
Flamming cheese sans the flame!
Flamming cheese sans the flame!
For entree I chose the Greek Combo Platter which came with Pastitso (Greek lasagna), Mousaka, Dolmades (stuffed grape leaves), Gyro/ tzatzik, and my choice of soup or salad, and rice pilaf, vegetable, oven roasted potatoes, or french fries. I chose the lemon egg chicken soup and the rice pilaf. Both were excellent choices. The soup had a velvety texture with nice chunks of chicken and orizo. It had a nice lemony finish. My dad got the same entree and chose the house salad instead. The salad was nice but I preferred the soup.
The platter was massive! The amount of Gyro alone could have been two meals...tacking on the lasagna, mousaka, and grape leaves plus a huge mound of rice pilaf was just ridiculous. Knowing I couldn't finish it all, I tried a little bit of everything. The Gyro meat was delicious almost on par with the Mediterranean Deli in Winter Park (still the best if you ask me). The grape leaves were very flavorful as well packed with rice, beef, and spices. The downers on the plate were the pastitso and mousaka which lacked any real flavor at all. It seemed like someone had forgotten to put in the salt. That was disappointing. The rice pilaf was very good though which sort of made up for it. My dad got the oven roasted potatoes which were sitting in a lemon buttery sauce. Incredible!
Greek Combo Platter...more like a mountain!
The rice could be a meal all in itself.
Oven roasted potatoes...delish!
Gyro sandwich...a real monster
My mom's Gyro Platter w/ the vegetable of the day--green beans
We had coupons for free dessert with the entrees. They were all out of baklava so we got a cake-like sweet; it was cream of wheat in the center, really thick so it could be sliced in between filo dough. The filo dough had been soaked in sugar syrup and then the entire thing had been drizzled in honey before serving. It was a peculiar dessert but I enjoyed it, even more so than Hellas.The rice could be a meal all in itself.
Oven roasted potatoes...delish!
Gyro sandwich...a real monster
My mom's Gyro Platter w/ the vegetable of the day--green beans
Mamma's didn't disappoint and neither did Tarpon Springs, a very unique community worth the day trip. I think in their hearts my family really is Greek. Opa!